Home > Gaming Guides > Turn On MLB The Show 23 Guess Pitch

MLB The Show 23 Guess Pitch: How To Turn On

Published Date :

Unable to find the MLB The Show 23 Guess Pitch setting? While batting in The Show 23, it is crucial to strategize the incoming pitch. If not, there are chances that the pitcher can outrival you by striking you out. Guess Pitch is one of the optional features that allow you to guess the incoming Pitch. You can get bonuses and penalties by guessing the pitches correctly or incorrectly. But several players are unable to find the setting to enable or disable it. Not to worry, check our guide on how to turn on and off Guess Pitch to find out.

How to Turn On MLB The Show 23 Guess Pitch

mlb the show 23 guess pitch

You can find the Guess Pitch in MLB The Show 23 by heading to the Offense section under the Control tab. You can head here by selecting the Control tab under the Gameplay setting. As you head there, you can find the Guess Pitch option at the bottom. From there, toggle the options for Guess Pitch to choose your preferred setting.

So, here’s how you can turn on the Guess Pitch:

  • Head to Settings from the Main Menu and select the Gameplay section.
  • Press the right trigger (RT) twice on your controller to open the Offense options under the Control tab.
  • Scroll down to Guess Pitch and toggle options for the preferred Guess pitch.

In total, there are four Guess Pitches options that you can choose from in The Show 23. These are as follows:

  • No Feedback
  • Classic
  • Quadrant
  • PCI

Every Guess pitch has its set of bonuses, penalties, and feedback. No Feedback offers the highest bonuses and lower penalties while Classic Guess Pitch offers lower bonuses. In my opinion, the guess pitch is best suited to grasp the batting or hitting technique better. But relying on the Guess Pitch during Online play or PvP can be a bit unpredictable.

How to Use Guess Pitch (Controls)

Here’s how you can use Guess Pitch on all the supported platforms:

  • Xbox One & Series X | S: Press RT + A, B, X, or Y buttons
  • PS5 & PS4: Press R2 + X, O, Square, or Triangle buttons

That’s everything covered about how to turn on the MLB The Show 23 Guess Pitch. If you liked this guide, check out our guides on how to throw to first base, how to farm XP, how to change Pitching style, and more MLB The Show 23 Guides right here on Gamer Tweak.

  • Run a Dance Studio Codes (September 2026)

    Run a Dance Studio Codes (September 2026)

    Published Date :

    From hiring your first dancer to putting together competition-ready routines, Run a Dance Studio lets you grow a small studio into a thriving dance business. You can recruit dancers and teachers, unlock new features, and manage different parts of your studio as it expands. Codes can give you useful rewards to help along the way… Read More

  • Car Duels Codes (September 2026)

    Car Duels Codes (September 2026)

    Published Date :

    Car Duels is a Roblox vehicle battle game where two teams compete in an arena by ramming enemy cars and pushing them off the edge. You need to stay on the platform while trying to knock the opposing team into the water. Cash can be used to get different vehicles and change the bumpers, so… Read More

  • Poly Loot Codes (September 2026)

    Poly Loot Codes (September 2026)

    Published Date :

    Poly Loot is a Roblox action RPG where you battle monsters, collect equipment, and explore new areas as your character gets stronger. While you’re on that adventure, you can improve your weapons, armor, and mounts while taking on tougher enemies. Take a look at the current Poly Loot codes and their rewards below. Last checked… Read More

  • Steal a Chicken Codes (September 2026)

    Steal a Chicken Codes (September 2026)

    Published Date :

    Think you can sneak into a chicken nest, grab a bird, and make it back before you’re caught? Steal a Chicken puts you in exactly that situation, letting you collect chickens, sell eggs for Cash, and upgrade your Speed as you build up your progress. Codes can give you extra cash and temporary boosts to… Read More