The Hey Arnold! mission gives Jason one of his first important decisions in GTA 6. After chasing down Brian Heder’s former business associate, Arnold, you’ll corner him at the docks and have to decide what to do. You can follow Brian’s instructions and kill Arnold or let him leave after he promises to stay quiet.
Neither option changes the immediate outcome of the mission, but your decision affects Jason’s Criminal Profile. Here’s what happens when you kill Arnold, spare him, or simply wait for him to make his escape.
Kill or Spare Arnold in GTA 6: All Choice Outcomes
| Your Choice | Result |
|---|---|
| Kill Arnold | Jason receives a Hardened Criminal Profile rating. Arnold is permanently removed from the story. |
| Spare Arnold | Jason receives a Restrained Criminal Profile rating. Arnold swims away after promising to keep quiet. |
| Wait without choosing | Arnold eventually decides to swim away. This counts as sparing him and gives Jason a Restrained rating. |
Should You Kill or Spare Arnold in GTA 6?

Spare Arnold to Get a Restrained Criminal Profile
If you let Arnold go, Jason receives a Restrained rating on his Criminal Profile. This moves him towards the less violent side of the system and affects how he develops his Focus.
You also avoid killing someone who has already surrendered. Arnold promises to leave Brian’s business alone, jumps into the water, and swims away from the docks.
Sparing him is enough to satisfy Brian. Jason later tells Brian that Arnold won’t cause any more trouble, and Brian accepts the explanation. You don’t need to execute Arnold to complete the mission or progress through the story.
Some guides also report a later callback involving Arnold, with Brian sending Jason a message and a $10,000 payment. However, other walkthroughs state that Arnold never returns. Treat this as a reported possibility rather than a guaranteed reward for sparing him.
Kill Arnold to Get a Hardened Criminal Profile
If you decide Arnold is too dangerous to leave alive, Jason can shoot him at the docks. Doing so gives him a Hardened Criminal Profile rating, pushing him further towards a more ruthless playstyle.
The main downside is that Arnold is permanently removed from the story, so you won’t have the possibility of any later interaction or callback involving him.
There is no immediate mission advantage to killing him. Brian accepts the outcome either way, and the story continues without requiring Arnold’s death.
What Happens If You Don’t Make a Choice?
You can also avoid making the decision yourself. If you wait at the docks instead of selecting either option, Arnold eventually says that he’ll swim away.
He then jumps into the water and escapes. The game treats this as sparing Arnold, so Jason receives the Restrained Criminal Profile rating.
In other words, waiting gives you the same result as choosing to let him go. You don’t need to shoot him or select the non-lethal option manually.
Does Killing or Sparing Arnold Change the Story?
The immediate aftermath of Hey Arnold! remains the same regardless of your decision. Jason returns to Brian and explains that Arnold won’t cause any more trouble. Brian accepts this and introduces Jason to his associate Kenton Rees.
This introduction leads to the next story mission, Island Dreams, so neither choice blocks your main story progress.
The main confirmed difference is Jason’s Criminal Profile. Reports about a later Arnold-related callback are inconsistent, so don’t assume that sparing him guarantees another mission or encounter.
So Which Choice Should You Make?
I’d recommend sparing Arnold. You receive the Restrained rating instead of moving towards a more violent Criminal Profile, and you don’t lose anything in the immediate story progression. It also leaves open the possibility of the later callback reported by some guides.
However, if you’re playing Jason as a ruthless criminal who doesn’t leave loose ends, killing Arnold fits that approach. It won’t prevent you from completing the story or meeting Kenton.
Ultimately, this is a relatively minor decision in the larger campaign. Choose based on the kind of character you want Jason to become.











