Home > Baldur’s Gate 3 > BG3: Should Shadowheart Become A Dark Justiciar?

BG3: Should Shadowheart Become A Dark Justiciar?

Published Date :

Shadowheart is one of the prime characters in Baldur’s Gate 3 that you can have on your team. While she is on your team, you will have to make numerous choices that will shape the story going forward. Since players would want to know the consequences of their choice before moving forward, they are bugged on whether they should let Shadowheart become a Dark Justiciar in BG3 or not. This guide is all you will need to make the choice for yourself.

With almost every character, you will need to make some of the other choices that will help you progress the story in the direction of those choices. As a result, it will be important to know the consequences of the choices you would want to make. Since players are worried that they might up losing Shadowheart, they are confused if they should let her be the Dark Justiciar in Baldur’s Gate 3.

Should Shadowheart Become a Dark Justiciar in BG3?

Should Shadowheart Become a Dark Justiciar in Baldur's Gate 3
Image via Larian Studios

If Shadowheart is to become a Dark Justiciar in Baldur’s Gate 3, she will have to kill Nightsong in Act 2 of the game. However, the consequences of killing Nightsong are far worse than if you don’t kill her. Additionally, if you are looking to romance Shadowheart, you would not want her to become a Dark Justiciar since she will now fully embrace being one of Shar’s chosen.

If that’s not enough, you should also know that everyone in Last Light dies which means you might just deprive yourself of some useful quests. So, if you were to ask me if you should let Shadowheart become a Dark Justiciar in BG3, the answer would be no. The consequences far outweigh the benefits of doing so.

That’s all you will need on whether you should let Shadowheart become a Dark Justiciar in BG3. If you found this guide useful, do check out our other Baldur’s Gate 3 guides in our dedicated section here at Gamer Tweak.

  • Anime Heaven Codes (November 2026)

    Anime Heaven Codes (November 2026)

    Published Date :

    You start off with zero power in Anime Heaven, so you just train a bit, fight basic enemies, and slowly unlock cool anime moves. Once you get stronger, you can hop over to new islands, do quests, and try harder game modes to get better rewards. I put all the working Anime Heaven codes below… Read More

  • Everveil Codes (November 2026)

    Everveil Codes (November 2026)

    Published Date :

    You can just chill and explore at your own speed in Everveil instead of rushing through endless fights. Some days you might feel like fishing or riding your horse across the map, and other days you can roll for one of 14 magic elements, craft new swords, and take on big bosses like Cerberus. I… Read More

  • Arise Crossover Codes (November 2026)

    Arise Crossover Codes (November 2026)

    Updated Date :

    Arise Crossover lets you explore new islands, sail across the map, and take down tough raid bosses and your journey gets a whole lot easier when your weapons and shadow army are properly leveled up. Make sure to redeem the working Arise Crossover codes below to grab free Tickets, Gems, Cash, and Spins so you… Read More

  • Kizuna Codes (November 2026)

    Kizuna Codes (November 2026)

    Published Date :

    Kizuna drops you into a dark anime world packed with fast melee fights, supernatural powers, and deep character customization. Getting the exact clan or traits you want for your build takes a lot of luck, so having a big stash of free spins makes a huge difference. You can claim up to 180 free Rerolls… Read More