AC Valhalla Gudrun Or Holger – Who Is Right?

Not sure how to resolve the dispute of who is right between Gudrun or Holger in Assassin's Creed Valhalla? This guide will help you decide.

You will get to decide who is right Gudrun or Holger in AC Valhalla. It is part of the Blame and Sail quest. Here you have to resolve the dispute over sailcloth. Let us learn everything about the quest and who you should pick in Gudrun or Holger in Assassin’s Creed Valhalla.

Who is Right Gudrun or Holger in AC Valhalla?

ac valhalla gudrun or holger
Image Credit: theNumbskull on YouTube

Once the Blame and Sail quest begins you will have to decide on who is Right Gudrun or Holger. The choice you should go here with is I support Sigurd’s judgment. You might be wondering this was not the decision, keep reading as I explain this choice.

So in this quest, you will first hear the story from both sides.

  • Gudrun will say explain how Holger stole the sailcloth from her and defaced it. Thus she will ask him to repay for it.
  • In Holger’s turn, he will explain how he mistook the sailcloth for abandoned goods and took it. He doubles down as to if he would have stolen it why would he display the sailcloth.
  • Next both of them will start arguing and Eivor will stop them.
  • Here you can pick either option because no matter whom you pick is right Sigurd will interrupt and give the final judgment.
  • And in his judgment, he will declare Holger a thief and punish him by making him pay Gudrun for 30 sailcloths.
  • This is where the real choice comes in.
  • Once Sigurd announces his decision Holger will request you to do something about the unfair decision. Here you get two choices:
    • This judgment is unfair.
    • I support Sigurd’s judgment.
  • When you go along with Sigurd you end up with him on good terms. So if you want a better ending with him go along with Sigurd. Another reason is even if you do defy him the outcome will still be the same where Holger gets the punishment.

Hence, the answer to this choice is I support Sigurd’s judgment.

That covers this guide on who is right Gudrun or Holger in AC Valhalla. If you need more help on this game then check out our Assassin’s Creed Valhalla guides.