While completing the Mane and Tail quest that begins as a part of another larger quest named Reporting on East Anglia, you will have to act as a judge and choose who is right between Rowan vs Holger in AC Valhalla. In this AC Valhalla Rowan or Holger choice consequences guide, we will discuss the outcome of both the choices and help you with which is the right choice in our opinion.
AC Valhalla: Rowan is Right or Holger is Right
To put it simply, Holger according to us is the right choice in the AC Valhalla Rowan or Holger judgment quest. Let’s delve deep into the consequences of each choice so that you yourself can see why we choose Holger over Rowan. The Mane and Tail quest begins when Holger cuts some of the hairs from Rowan’s Horse’s tail.
AC Valhalla: Selecting Rowan is Right Choice Consequence
If you select this option, Eivor will say that Holger has done wrong and that cutting down the tail has lowered the market value of the horse. Hence, Eivor says that Holger should pay for the damage done to Rowan’s horse. However, despite paying the money, Holger will not get to keep the horse. Hence, he will be displeased and they both will leave.
AC Valhalla: Selecting Holger is Right Choice Consequence
If you choose this option, Eivor will say that the horse’s tail’s hair will grow back. Hence, there is no permanent damage done to anyone. However, Eivor will ask Holger to apologize for what he has done and warns him to never repeat it. At Eivor’s request, Rowan will accept the apology and they both will leave happily as friends.
As you can see, choosing Holger is right for Rowan vs Holger in AC Valhalla is certainly the better choice to make here. One thing to note here is that the choice that you make in this quest only lasts until the quest is over and does not have any long-term effect on the gameplay.
That’s the end of our AC Valhalla Rowan or Holger right choice consequences guide. If you want to read more such guides on AC Valhalla, ensure visiting our Wiki page that includes several tips and tricks that will help you progress quickly in the game. For instance, you can read boss fight guides such as how to defeat Fenrir and the Walloper. You can also read about how to unlock AC Valhalla’s secret ending.