Home > Hogwarts Legacy > Should I Tell Natty Truth Hogwarts Legacy

Should I Tell The Truth To Natty In Hogwarts Legacy?

Published Date :

After the prologue of Hogwarts Legacy, you carry the secrets of ancient magic with you but should you tell Natty the truth? Natsai Onai or ‘Natty’ is one of the earliest students that you get introduced to. You also get to do school activities with her and get to know her. She even tells you about her life before coming to Hogwarts. Building this friendship with her might influence your decision on telling her the truth or not. Let’s learn more about this in detail.

Should I tell Natty the truth in Hogwarts Legacy?

natty dialogue truth hogwarts legacy

In Hogwarts Legacy, Natty will ask you to meet at Lower Hogsfield after you get to know her. When you meet her here she will ask you about what happened in Hogsmeade. These are the options you will have as replies:

  • They want something I found.
  • I can’t say.

If you choose the first option and tell the truth, Natty will know about ancient magic. She will tell you that she does not know what it is. She will still have trust in you.

If you choose the second option and hide the truth, Natty will believe you but she will also find it odd. She will still understand that you have your reasons.

So ultimately, it does not matter what you choose to tell to Natty in Hogwarts Legacy. This is more of an immersion thing, and the only difference between both is the different dialogues you get from it. While this can be a bit disappointing, it is also a good thing that you can’t really mess up your playthrough because you choose the wrong option. Often in games, decisions like these can lead to the character’s demise and things like that. Such is not the case in Hogwarts Legacy.

So be assured that no matter if you tell the truth, your relationship with Natty will stay the same. For more Hogwarts Legacy guides like this, check out our other articles like how to get a Breeding Pen and should you help Ackley Barnes in Hogwarts Legacy.

  • Technical Ragdoll MMA Codes (November 2026)

    Technical Ragdoll MMA Codes (November 2026)

    Published Date :

    Your fighter’s body size actually decides how you fight in Technical Ragdoll MMA. Changing your height, muscle, and weight changes your reach, speed, and stamina across five weight classes, whether you want to throw punches, kick, or take opponents down to the mat. I listed the working Technical Ragdoll MMA codes below so you can… Read More

  • Submerged Codes (November 2026)

    Submerged Codes (November 2026)

    Published Date :

    Submerged puts you and your friends inside a submarine, exploring deep, dark ocean layers where massive sea monsters are always hunting you. Someone has to steer while the rest of the crew fixes hull leaks, shoots at threats, or swims outside in a diving suit to patch damage before the sub sinks. Buying better submarines… Read More

  • Net a Fish Codes (November 2026)

    Net a Fish Codes (November 2026)

    Published Date :

    Throw a giant net into the water in Net a Fish, pull up rare catches, and drop them in your pool so they make cash for you every second. You have to keep upgrading your nets and boats if you want to explore new worlds, survive Megalodon attacks, and catch huge sea monsters like the… Read More

  • Anime Mini Fighters Codes (November 2026)

    Anime Mini Fighters Codes (November 2026)

    Published Date :

    Your tiny anime squad keeps farming Coins for you even after you log off in Anime Mini Fighters, so you always come back to extra cash. You roll dice to summon stronger fighters, hunt for rare Celestial units and mutations, and push your team through 20 worlds and up the Heavenly Tower. Check out the… Read More