Should I Free Penny In Hogwarts Legacy? (Answered)

Free Penny or not in Hogwarts Legacy? Check what each choice does.

If you’re wondering whether you should free Penny in Hogwarts Legacy then you’re at the right place. In this action RPG, you’ll get to explore the magical Hogwarts Castle and its surrounding areas like the Hogsmeade Village. Fans of the Harry Potter books know that the wizarding world is full of magical creatures and beasts. Among those are the House Elves. These creatures possess powerful magic but they are extremely loyal to their masters. This can lead to them being mistreated. In Hogwarts Legacy, you’ll come across one such Elf in a quest called and we’ll tell you what to do next.

Should You Free Penny in Hogwarts Legacy?

Penny Stays at the Shop

In Hogwarts Legacy, it does not matter if you free Penny or not since the outcome will be the same. Once you complete the “Minding Your Own Business” quest, you can release Penny but she will continue to help you run the shop. And if you don’t, the result will be the same. Penny will stay because she always wanted to run a shop with a friend.

The good part about freeing her is that she will be very grateful to you and mention that you’re a kind and generous boss. Moreover, she’ll wear the hat you present her as a mark of a free elf. This is the same hat that you’ll find in St. Mungo’s Dungeon.

However, if you are planning to be evil in Hogwarts Legacy, then do not free Penny. Although it’s one of the dialogues that does not impact the game, it will be a nod to your character being evil.

To break it down, here are the choices you’ll get and their results:

Choice Result
“That’s good to hear” Penny will help you run the shop
“No need Penny, I am freeing you” Penny will still help you run the shop

After selecting any option, you’ll get to choose the name of the shops here are the options:

  • Vesters & Venum
  • Cladwell & Brewsters
  • Stitches & Draughts

This too won’t have an impact on the game.

We hope that answers your question about whether you should free Penny in Hogwarts Legacy. While you’re here, make sure you visit our Wiki guide for more such content.