Home > Gaming Guides > MLB The Show 23 Marketplace Buy & Sell

How To Buy & Sell Cards In MLB The Show 23 Marketplace

Published Date :

Want to know how to buy and sell cards in MLB The Show 23? Then you’re at the right place. If you have played FIFA or Madden, you’ll probably know how the buying and selling of player cards work. Well, the marketplace in MLB The Show 23 is quite similar too. If you are new to MLB games, then you will probably have a hard time navigating through the Marketplace. Keep reading our guide till the end to get up to speed with this feature.

How to Buy & Sell Cards in MLB The Show 23

marketplace mlb the show 23

Buying and selling player cards in MLB The Show 23 marketplace is not that complicated. But first, let’s talk about how to buy players in Diamond Dynasty. Here are the steps you need to follow on PlayStation and Xbox :

  1. From the Diamond Dynasty main menu, go to the “Shop” tab.
  2. Now, select “Marketplace” and then go to “MLB Players”.
  3. You will now see a list of randomized players for sale.
  4. You can also use the “Filters” option. On PlayStation, press the “Square” button, and on Xbox press the “X” button.
  5. Now you can search for the player you want or use Search Filters to find a specific player.
  6. To buy a player, select the card first by pressing the “X” button on PS and the “A’ button on Xbox.
  7. Now, a “Market Options” tab will open up.
  8. Select “Buy/Sell Options”.
  9. If you want to instantly purchase the player at the Buy Now price, then select the “Buy” option.
  10. However, if you want to get a better deal, we’d recommend you select the “Sell” Option.
  11. Using the Sell option will let you create a “Buy Order” of your choice.

As we said, if you select the “Sell” option, other users who own that player will sell it for the price that you have mentioned. So for example, if Jordan Montgomery’s buy now listing starts at 250 Stubs, you can get it for as low as 180 Stubs by using the Sell option.

Now that you know how to purchase your favorite player, learn how to sell a rare player card or a duplicate player in MLB The Show 23:

How to Sell Players in the Marketplace

If you want to sell players, you will need to follow the same steps mentioned above until you reach the “Buy/Sell” options. We will show you how to do the final bit:

  1. Once you have searched for the player that you want to discard, press the “Sell” option.
  2. Again, don’t select the “Sell Now” option if you want to earn more Stubs.
  3. Just select the “Sell Order” option. Enter your price and press “Finalise Order”.

Remember that since you are a seller, you will be charged a 10% tax on the total fee. Once you have placed your sell order, wait for the notification to pop up that confirms the sale of your player.

That’s all you need to know about how to buy and sell cards in MLB The Show 23 Marketplace. While you’re still here, check out more guides like these in our MLB The Show 23 section.

  • Resonance Solstice Codes (October 2026)

    Resonance Solstice Codes (October 2026)

    Updated Date :

    Running your armored train across the fractured continents of Gameduchy’s railway RPG demands careful trade planning between city-states and sharp tactical card synergies in real-time battles. Reconnecting isolated settlements and recruiting skilled crew members demands plenty of B.C.R.L. Coins and Chaos Stones to keep your locomotive upgraded. Our list of the latest Resonance Solstice codes… Read More

  • Shape of Dreams Codes (October 2026)

    Shape of Dreams Codes (October 2026)

    Published Date :

    Slashing through shifting dreamscapes and piecing together fractured memory realms, Lizard Smoothie’s action roguelike demands steady focus, quick reflexes, and style as you dodge lucid nightmares. Customizing your favorite wanderers adds fun visual flair as you chain essence abilities and tackle higher-difficulty loops. Redeeming from our list of active Shape of Dreams Codes gives you… Read More

  • MU New Dawn Codes (October 2026)

    MU New Dawn Codes (October 2026)

    Published Date :

    Revisiting MU’s continent in Webzen and FingerFun’s MU New Dawn thrusts you into sprawling guild territory sieges, wing crafting, and demon hunts across classic hunting grounds like Lorencia and Noria, plus towering World Bosses and Blood Castle tier climbs. Along the way, you’ll need more heavy investments in Jewels of Bless, Soul, and gold reserves… Read More

  • Motto Immortal Codes (October 2026)

    Motto Immortal Codes (October 2026)

    Published Date :

    Leading a squad of legendary deities against the Shadow-Blight’s spreading corruption in Motto Immortal demands sharp tactical card placement and a steady flow of summon resources. Purifying fallen gods, ascending mythical heroes, and clearing hard campaign chapters need large reserves of upgrade materials and summon pinions. Redeeming gift codes gives your lineup an immediate power… Read More