Home > Assassin's Creed Valhalla > Whos Should be Jarl in Assassin's Creed Valhalla?

AC Valhalla: Who Should Be Jarl Choice Consequences Guide

Published Date :

One of the many choices that you have to make in Assassin’s Creed Valhalla is who should become the Jarl. This unlike many other choices that you get in the game can have a significant effect on your settlement. It all begins from the AC Valhalla Trygve – Under The Skin choice, and later on to the mission called “Farewells and Legacies.” Just so that you don’t end up making a wrong choice, we have made this Assassin’s Creed Valhalla choice consequences guide. This guide lists down all the choices and their consequences in Trygve – Under The Skin choice quest and how it impacts your settlement.

Assassin’s Creed Valhalla Trygve – Under The Skin Choice Consequences Guide

The Trygve – Under The Skin choice quest gives two choices: “Snotinghamscire can’t lose another” and “Do as you must, Trygve.” Putting it straightforward, we would suggest going with the “can’t lose another option.” Here’s why:

AC Valhalla: Snotinghamscire Can’t Lose Another Choice Consequences

Selecting this option will make Eivor talk Trygve out of throwing himself into the fire and give his life to gods. This option will let Trygve stay in the game so that you can later make a decision to make him Jarl.

AC Valhalla: Do as You Must, Trygve Choice Consequences

Selecting this option will let Tyrgve throw himself into the burning flames and sacrifice his life.
Now, since you know the consequences of each choice, let’s see how it will affect your settlement through the “Farewells and Legacies” mission.

Assassin’s Creed Valhalla: Who Should be Jarl

who should be jarl in ac valhalla

We suggest to choose Trygve as the Jarl, this will let Vili join your settlement. But all this will be possible if you would have saved Trygve in the “Under The Skin” choice. During the “Farewells and Legacies” mission in Snotinghamscire, you will again have a choice to make. This time the choice will be on who should become Jarl in Assassin’s Creed Valhalla. The choice will be between Trygve (Earldorman) and Vili. The choices and consequences will be:

I see a jarl in you: This will make Vili the Jarl and no one will join your settlement. This will be a default option if Trygve would have died.

I see Trygve as jarl, and you with me: Selecting this choice will make Trygve the Jarl, and Vili will join your settlement.

That’s the reason why we recommended to choose “Snotinghamscire can’t lose another” and “I see Trygve as jarl, and you with me” options. While here, ensure reading our guides on how to complete the Lamp Chops world event, activate the three slot statue, find the Unholy Father, and defeat Loki in Assassin’s Creed Valhalla.

  • UMA DASH Codes (November 2026)

    UMA DASH Codes (November 2026)

    Published Date :

    The best part of UMA DASH is holding onto your ultimate until the last few seconds and flying past everyone right at the finish line. You can test out different perks to make your runner faster, and having extra Gold and spins makes trying new stuff way easier. I put all the working UMA DASH… Read More

  • Undertale Fight Codes (November 2026)

    Undertale Fight Codes (November 2026)

    Published Date :

    Are you looking to get more Gold and Lucky Rolls in Undertale Fight? The latest Undertale Fight codes can give you both, with some offering up to 35 Lucky Rolls and 20K Gold multiplied by your current multiplier. Make sure to redeem them before they expire. Last checked for new codes on: November 13, 2026… Read More

  • Arasaka Academy Codes (November 2026)

    Arasaka Academy Codes (November 2026)

    Published Date :

    This Cyberpunk 2077 inspired game actually feels like jumping straight into Night City. You pull jobs straight from your in-game phone, earn some cash, and start swapping out weak gear for rare Cyberware upgrades as you climb the ranks. Rerolls are huge when you want to switch up your build or fix bad starter traits,… Read More

  • A Bizarre Run Codes (November 2026)

    A Bizarre Run Codes (November 2026)

    Published Date :

    Trying to pull a good Stand from an Arrow in A Bizarre Run is pure luck, and nobody wants to get stuck with a bad kit when the starting gun goes off. You need a steady stash of Rokas to clear out bad rolls until you find a power that actually wins fights. Below are… Read More